FormPanel Validation with Nested User Controls

[jtorkels]

Hi,

My forms were submitting fine using 2.1. After updating to 2.2, myform.getForm().isValid() is returning false even though all the required fields are filled out. I suspect that the problem is either the way the user controls are nested inside the formpanel or something was changed with the allowblank attribute in 2.2. I hoping you could point me in the right direction. Here is an example of the nested user controls:

<ext:FormPanel runat="server" ID="lspFormPanel" Width="860" ButtonAlign="Center" >
    <Items>
        <%--Panel that contains General Instructions--%>
        <ext:Panel ID="lspInstructions" runat="server" Header="false" Border="false" Hidden="false" Layout="FitLayout" >
            <Content>
                <uc1:Instructions ID="ucInstruct" runat="server" />
            </Content>
        </ext:Panel>
    </Items>
    <Buttons>
        <ext:Button ID="btnSave" runat="server" Text="Save" Height="40" Icon="Disk" OnDirectClick="click_Save" />
        <ext:Button ID="btnCancel" runat="server" Text="Cancel" Height="40" Icon="Cross" OnDirectClick="click_Cancel" />
        <ext:Button ID="btnSubmit" runat="server" Text="Submit" Height="40" Icon="BasketAdd" >
             <DirectEvents>
                <Click OnEvent="checkValidation" ><Confirmation ConfirmRequest="true" Message="Are you sure that you want to submit this course proposal? No changes can be made after the initial submission." />
                    <EventMask ShowMask="true" Msg="Proposal is Submitting..." /> 
                </Click>
            </DirectEvents>
             <Listeners>
               <Click Handler = "if (#{lspFormPanel}.getForm().isValid()) return true; else{Ext.Msg.show({icon: Ext.MessageBox.ERROR, msg: 'Please check the fields and try again!', buttons:Ext.Msg.OK}); return false;}" />
            </Listeners>
        </ext:Button>
    </Buttons>
</ext:FormPanel>

Here is an example of the layout I use inside the user controls:

<ext:Panel ID="pnl1" runat="server" Layout="AnchorLayout" >
    <Items>
        <ext:Panel ID="pnlInstr" runat="server" Border="false" Layout="FormLayout" >
            <Items>
                <ext:Label ID="lbl1" runat="server" Html="Test1" />
                <ext:Label ID="lbl2" runat="server" Html="Test2" />
            </Items>
        </ext:Panel>
    </Items>
</ext:Panel>

[Vladimir]

I cannot reproduce it, for me true value is returned
Please post runable test case

[jtorkels]

You can close this case. I was destroying an embedded user control that had allowBlank = false listed as a default parameter. In 2.1, the user control was destroyed and allowBlank = false was ignored and now in 2.2 it is not. I set each field to be allowBlank = true before destroying and now it works. Thanks!